Is SHR (for SO & OM) and CRP (for CO) Combination Allowed in RMA (P400511)?

Goal

Question> Is it possible to have both SO|OM & CO|OM in a single RMA document?

BUSINESS SCENARIO
(Sales Order)

1. Sales Order is placed with quantity 60
2. Confirmed Shipment with quantity 60
3. Invoiced with 60
4. Closed

(Customer has returned quantity 50 which does not meet the requirement)
5. Customer returned quantity 50
6. Purchase Order and Receipt with 50 (to credit quantity 50)
    6.1. Quantity 40 to repair/rework location
    6.2. Quantity 10 to scrap location
7. CO is created and credit memo is issued for quantity 50

(Customer still needs the quantity 50 to assemble end product, but the my capacity is 40 at this moment)

8. Ship quantity 40

So a single RMA to record this transaction,
- Receipt of returned components (scrap & rework)
- Credit Order for returned goods
- Sales Order for reworked - 40
: Is it feasible to maintain this transaction in a single RMA?


Solution

No. P400511 does not allow you to create both Sales Order and Credit Order with same RMA Number in initial ADD mode. You must first save the RMA with First disposition Code (SHR / Sales Order)), and then reinquire to add a second Disposition Code (CRP / Credit Order).

Example of data entry:

Last Disposition RMA Item Number RMA Item Description RMA Quantity RMA Line No Inventory Item for Receipt Other Columns
SHR KOPI-C Black Coffee 40 1 KOPI-C ...
CRP KOPI-C Black Coffee 50 2


Above entry is to issue a hard error with error code "40R1 - Disposition Code Invalid" when you populating the first row SHR (to create SO and OM) and CRP (CO only).

This form has 1 Errors 0 Warnings

Disposition Code Invalid
CAUSE.... Only one disposition may be selected at Return Material Authorization entry time.
RESOLUTION.... All lines being entered must have the same disposition.
ER Details:
     Form P400511_W400511E
     Control Id 314
     Control Title DispositionChanged
     Event Button clicked
     Line No 57
     Error ID 40R1



Reason for error

: Validation routine: Set error when the special handling code of Last Disposition conjunction between (2 or 5 = SO) and (6 or 7 = CO). Hence below combinations are not allowed,

: In other words, a single RMA can not hold both SO and CO (whether you create CO from history or on the fly.)

UDC 40/RN - Returned Material Status

Below

Codes Description 01 Description 02 Special Handling
CLS Close Line Item 4
CRP Create a Credit Order Creates a Credit Memo 6
CRR Credit and Receive Item Creates a Credit Memo and OM 7
NOC No Credit Order Allowed 1
PLR Recommend an Item Shipment or Receipt 3
REC Create Purchase Order Creates a Purchase Order 1
S0P Create SO w/ Zero Price Creates SO w/ Zero Prices 2
S0R Ship & Receive Item Zero Price Creates SO w/ 0 Price and OM 5
SHP Create Sales Order with Price Creates a Sales Order w/ Price 2
SHR Ship and Receive Item w/ Price Creates SO w/ Price & OM 5
VEN Create PO for Vendor Return Create a PO to Vendor



Special Handling Code:

The usage of special handling codes of UDC 40/RN (do not change any because it controls the behavior/functionality of P400511.